BLB Solicitors
  • +01225 755656
  • enquiries@blbsolicitors.co.uk
BLB Solicitors
  • +01225 755656
  • enquiries@blbsolicitors.co.uk
  • Home
  • Services for You
    • Conveyancing Solicitors
    • Leasehold Solicitors
    • Property Dispute Solicitors
    • Divorce, Family Law and Mediation
    • Lifetime Planning and Wills
    • Probate and Estate Administration
    • Equity Release Solicitors
    • Retirement Property Conveyancing
    • Personal Injury Compensation
    • Medical Negligence Solicitors
  • Services for Business
    • Commercial Property
    • Commercial Property Disputes
    • Corporate & Commercial Legal Advice
    • Estate Management Solicitors
  • BLB Solicitors Locations
    • Almondsbury Solicitors
    • Bath Solicitors
    • Bristol Solicitors
    • Bradford on Avon Solicitors
    • Swindon Solicitors
    • Trowbridge Solicitors
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Working for BLB
    • BLB Solicitors – How we work
    • Making Payments to BLB Solicitors
    • Instructing BLB Solicitors
    • Terms of Business
    • Complaints Policy
    • Interest Policy
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Home » A lesson in the importance of Wills

Lifetime Planning and Wills
Last Will and Testament and pen
Jul 5th, 2019

At BLB Solicitors, our goal is simple – to deliver you clear, practical legal advice and cost-effective solutions. We hope you enjoy exploring our Blog. If you can’t find what you’re looking for, please do contact us.

A lesson in the importance of Wills

A story of warring step-siblings has recently gained much attention and serves as a valuable lesson in the importance of making a Will. Trowbridge Wills specialist Jenny Greenland considers the case further.

First – The Legal Presumption

Section 184 of the Law of Property Act 1925 states that if two or more people die in circumstances where it is not possible to determine who died first, the younger is deemed to survive the elder. In a rare case the High Court has been asked to adjudicate on this this legal presumption.

What are the facts?

John and Ann Scarle were both found dead in their home in October 2016 having suffered with hypothermia. John and Ann each had one daughter from a previous relationship. No expert has been able to say conclusively who died first and therefore a disagreement has arisen between the daughters in relation to the inheritance.

Mr and Mrs Scarle’s main asset was their house, which was owned jointly. Whoever, however briefly, lived longer would have inherited the whole house on the first death. On their subsequent death, possibly only moments later, the whole house would then pass to that individual’s daughter.

Therefore, one daughter will inherit the house, worth around £280,000. The other daughter will receive nothing.

The law

Section 184 of the Law of Property Act 1925 is also known as the “Commorientes Rule” meaning “simultaneous death”. The very purpose of this principle is to avoid any doubt as to what should happen to an inheritance if it is not possible to determine who died first.

So, why the doubt?

Anna Winter, Mr Scarle’s daughter, insists that the evidence shows that ‘on the balance of probabilities’ Mrs Scarle died first. If Mrs Scarle died first, Mr Scarle would have inherited on her death. On Mr Scarle’s subsequent death Ms Winter would then receive the entire estate.

Debroah Cutler, Mrs Scarle’s daughter’s believes that as there is uncertainty as to the order of the deaths, the legal presumption should be adopted. She states that Ms Winter needs to rebut this presumption ‘beyond reasonable doubt’. If Mr Scarle died first, Mrs Scarle would have inherited on his death. On Mrs Scarle’s subsequent death Ms Cutler would then receive the entire estate.

‘The balance of probabilities‘ is the civil burden of proof in England and Wales whereas ‘beyond reasonable doubt‘ is the burden of proof in the criminal law. Ms Winter’s argument therefore does hold weight. It is not clear whether this is enough to sway the judge away from the law enshrined in statute.

We await judgment.

How could this have been avoided?

If Mr and Mrs Scarle had prepared Wills they could have ensured that both their daughter’s inherited from their estate thus avoiding litigation. It is very common, these days, for people to have second marriages and children from previous relationships. Whilst this is normal in our society, our legislation has not caught up. To ensure a fair and equal distribution of your estate after your death (and in case of a simultaneous death) you must make a Will.

Contact

To discuss making or reviewing your Will, please contact Jenny Greenland on 01225 755656.

Jenny Greenland
Request a Call Back

Recent Articles

  • The danger of using AI to update Wills
  • What happens to pets when you die?
  • Letter of Wishes: do I need one?
  • Families urged to act now and plan ahead for upcoming changes to Inheritance Tax
  • Leaving money to charity in your Will

Newsletter Sign-up

* indicates required

Share this article

You may also like...
  • Jan 14th, 2025
    Can a parent disinherit a child?
    Read Article
  • Feb 5th, 2025
    Families urged to act now and plan ahead for upcoming changes to Inheritance Tax
    Read Article
View All Related Articles
Get in-touch today
Contact Form

Left Column

Right Column

Centre

 
Sending
  • Bristol Solicitors

    0117 905 5308
  • Bath Solicitors

    01225 462871
  • Bradford on Avon Solicitors

    01225 866541
  • Swindon Solicitors

    01793 615011
  • Trowbridge Solicitors

    01225 755656
  • Almondsbury Solicitors

    0117 905 5308
Authorised & Regulated by Solicitors Regulation Authority (No. 636644)
©2025 BLB Solicitors | Terms | Privacy | Legal